Miracles happen every day

… as long as you don’t specify beforehand what miracle you might be interested in observing.

A very good friend of mine, nomasir, had an interesting post recently on his blog, referring to a British news article about a grandfather, father, and son who were all three born on the same day of the year.  The article suggested that this was a very unlikely occurrence.

Just how unlikely was the matter of debate in the blog post… and that discussion reminded me of an interesting article by Persi Diaconis, “Statistical Problems in ESP Research” (Science, July 14, 1978, 201(4351):131-136).  Diaconis has contributed a lot of interesting mathematics, with applications ranging from magic tricks to card shuffling to coin flipping to, in this case, evaluating– and usually debunking– claims of ESP (extra-sensory perception).

I had read the article before, but in the process of searching for it, I also stumbled across something I had not seen before: a series of letters in response to the article by several apparently less-than-impressed researchers in the field, along with a response from Diaconis.  I recommend both the article and the letters; it’s an interesting exchange, short and readable even for the non-mathematician.

My point of this post deals with what Diaconis refers to in the article as the “problem of multiple end points.”  (The relevant section of the article involves the experimental subject referred to as B.D.)  In the context of the coincidental birthdays mentioned above, we can calculate the (small) probability of that particular event… but is that probability really interesting or useful after the event has occurred, when we didn’t “bet on” the event before it occurred?

Suppose that, instead of three generations of men all having the same birthday, they had all died on the same day of the year.  Or maybe it was a grandmother instead of a grandfather, or daughter instead of a son, etc.  Or maybe the three birthdays were all within just one or two days of each other.  These would all still be “interesting” occurrences.  Now– what is the probability that some one (or more) of these various “interesting” events might occur?

Quoting Diaconis again, “the odds against a coincidence of some sort are dramatically less than those against any prespecified particular one of them.”

I am reminded of the story of David Wilkerson, a man who claimed to have been inspired to make hundreds of peanut butter sandwiches on the night of 10 September 2001, which were then fed to rescue workers and victims after the terrorist attacks, the idea being that such inspiration was somehow a prediction of the attacks.  (This claim has since been discredited, but that’s not the point, so let’s suppose for example that it did actually happen.)  As one news story at the time described it, “What were [the sandwiches] for?  Who would eat them?  That part wasn’t clear [my emphasis]…”

Now suppose that tonight you stay up all night making peanut butter sandwiches.  What is the probability that you will not find some good use for them, even if it’s not in response to an unnatural disaster with global impact?

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Miracles happen every day

  1. nomasir says:

    Good post.

    A minor point in David Wilkerson’s defense, though I assure you it is minor and he doesn’t need my help in defense. The peanut butter sandwiches story appears to be a bit of false reporting; perhaps somebody trying to help out too much. Times Square Church (Wilkerson’s church) is up front with the fact that there were no sandwiches made on the 10th – they were made on the 11th after the attacks.

    It does point to a rather interesting twist on the argument. As you point out in the title – “Miracles happen every day as long as you don’t specify what miracles you’re looking for.” We see the “dual space” realization from people of faith all the time. Here I mean “people of faith” in a broad sense – people with a commitment to this or that ideology as morally superior. Such people will often take any event as proof of their faith.

    I remember when the Tsunamis hit the Indian Ocean in 2004. Some Christians claimed it was a sign of God’s wrath – for not being Christians. Some Muslims claimed it was a sign of God’ wrath – for not being good enough Muslims. Environmentalists claimed it was Mother Earth exacting retribution for global warming and pollution. I guess you can always shoehorn something in.

    In the Old Testament, prophecy went the other way. You had to call your shot before it happened – and if you were wrong, they’d stone you to death for being a false prophet. Now THAT will weed out the people who just want to latch on to any calamity for their own causes.

    Now, if I stayed up all night making peanut butter sandwiches, I’m sure I’d find a good use for them. I can point to at least two little boys who would help me dispatch them come morning light (though, one of them really would only help if I added jelly to the mix).

    • Good point, I was misleading when I suggested that there were no sandwiches, so to speak. The church did make and distribute sandwiches after the attacks.

      Only with jelly, huh? I’m telling you, peanut butter and sweet pickles are a great combination. Nobody seems to buy this. Maybe try it on the kids first?

  2. Beverly Lynn says:

    Peanut butter and pickles?!

    • Not just any pickles– *sweet* pickles. Although my memory is unclear, I think my mother liked them, but she at least introduced me to them when I was a kid, and I have loved them ever since. (Also, although I usually like crunchy peanut butter, smooth seems to work better in this case.)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.